Complaint for bad judgement [Jimmy]

[nephil]

1: Your ingame nickname?
nephilim
2) Moderator's nickname (as in subject).
Jimmy
3) Why you are not happy with Moderator's decision / behavior.
render bad decision

Administration updated the Flame Rules.
Indirect flame isnt considered as Family Related flame, he didnt specify any members.
Denied for Family Flame

I read the rules 7 times to confirm this, there is nothing about updated Flame Rules, nothing in notes, nothing about indirect flames, which is obviously bad judgement in this case because it was directed to me:

      c) Family related flame
          - Any insults or curses directed towards family members of a player are considered as family related flame.

Player is talking with me all the time, without reason he was searching for conflict, and if I answered, guess who would be reported here and banned, first he provoked, then he break the rules which is banable by your rules.
18:31    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    riki   (talking to me)
18:32    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    stop
18:37    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    fking ks
18:41    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    !votekick nep
18:41       [All]    [MOUSE_BREAKER] voted to kick [nephilim] [1/7]

19:04    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    this shit riki  (talking to me)
19:06    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    must be kicked

23:43    nephilim    [Allies]    bristle is a problem
23:48    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    u are the problem (talking to me)
23:51    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    FKING KSER
23:57    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    u tooke 2k gold from me
23:59    nephilim    [Allies]    stfu noob
23:59    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    BASTARD   (talking to me)
24:02    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    !f  (checking me before fucking my entire family and origin)
24:07    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    jebem ti semku  (i fuck your origin)
24:10    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    da ti najebem
24:16    nephilim    [Allies]    bices banovan
24:23    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    probaj xD
24:27    MOUSE_BREAKER    [Allies]    SMRADE  (my warning shut his mouth, he stopped because he knew he break the rules)

4) Forum link / Game link.
http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?topic=189324.0
http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?action=gameinfo;sa=game;gid=6243546



It is more than obvious he insulted my family and for that he should be banned because the rules show that, and I found exactly the same examples, unless we have double standards:

1 http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?topic=189228.0
06:44    bakaprase    [All]    LATENCY
06:46    bakaprase    [All]    PLSS
06:49    Preskill    [All]    shut up nub
06:55       [All]    FatAndViolent killed Preskill
06:57    Preskill    [All]    IDIOT
06:59    Preskill    [All]    RETARD
07:01    Preskill    [All]    SON OF WHORE
07:02    bakaprase    [All]    laggg
Almost the same case, here is questionable who was insulted, the guy who killed him or the one with lags, in my case he talked with me only and can't be someone third.

2 http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?topic=189340.0
25:20   Mission-[X]   [Allies]   mort
25:23   Mission-[X]   [Allies]   fuck your mother

Banned 1 Day
Family Flame

100% the same situation like in my case, but double standards

3 http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?topic=189186.0
In this case player was more raging than insulting any individual


Now more from MOUSE_BREAKER:

http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?action=gameinfo;sa=game;gid=6244245
09:11   dza_bu   [Allies]   -mute 10
09:16   MOUSE_BREAKER   [Allies]   jebem ti semku (same like in my case, fucking origin to another player, entire family...)

http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?action=gameinfo;sa=game;gid=6244111
31:26   -deynro-   [All]   look at mort
31:27   -deynro-   [All]   srsly
31:32   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   look at ur mom
31:36   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   NOT ON MORT
31:48   MOUSE_BREAKER   [Allies]   STUPID FLAMER

http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?action=gameinfo;sa=game;gid=6243902
18:39      [All]   [NvP.JokeR]QueSSWhO killed MOUSE_BREAKER
18:41   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   abe
18:43   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   sve da ti ebam (I fuck everything you have - family)
18:45   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   SO IMAS
18:50   QueSSWhO   [All]   aj sikter be
18:52   QueSSWhO   [All]   bot glup
18:54   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   MRSH
19:00   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   bot na tatkoti
19:05   QueSSWhO   [All]   Grob da nemas (you should not have a grave)
19:08   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   kreten
19:10   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   majka da nemas (your mother should die)
19:13   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   sve da ti ebam (I fuck everything you have - family)
24:56   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   this quess
24:58   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   pro
25:00   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   is banned
25:04   QueSSWhO   [All]   for what ?
25:10   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   for licking
25:10   QueSSWhO   [All]   1-7
25:12   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   ur mother
25:15   QueSSWhO   [All]   hes beter score then you
25:15   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   BUAHAHAHHAHA
25:16   QueSSWhO   [All]   for sure
25:22   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   pa i majkati imat
25:25   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   podobar scor
25:26   MOUSE_BREAKER   [All]   od mene
25:27   QueSSWhO   [All]   baned for
25:28   QueSSWhO   [All]   flame
25:30   QueSSWhO   [All]   !ignore mouse

Important, he said that he have admin friend, so I hope this player won't be protected because he is not a good guy, and as mentioned in request, I'm not asking for long ban, he was banned 2 times already for family related flame, but 1-2 days ban is ok for flamer.
If not, I guess every player can fuck family and origin to another player, if he is not using directly his nick when insulting, nor his hero and that is odd because insulting hero is not the same as insulting player/member of the game.

Thank you for your time. I invested more than a hour on this. Hope his friend Admin won't protect him as he said to me.

[Jimmy]

It was updated in private , it just wasnt updated on the scale.
But even before update , the translation of :
"Jebem ti semku"  or Serbian : "Jebem ti seme"
Is a common flame in Balkan slang.
You provided alot of games, and alot of chat from this player, but in your report, you used the one mentioned above , which is not bannable.
And last but not least , Mouse_Breaker doesnt have friends in Administration, and on the same note , im unsure if he has friends at all , while on that matter.

@-Aleksandar-  will solve this ,because you complained about my decision.
Regarding Updated flame Rule: http://dota.eurobattle.net/la/forum/index.php?topic=189280.msg693418#msg693418
You see who updated it , and why.

[cen]

We already had lengthy internal discussions what exactly falls under family related flame and sometimes it is not clear cut like in this case. To me personally this seems mild but I don't know enough Serbian to really get the gist of the insult so I'll let someone native decide. The english translation is certainly not bannable by my standards.