sw

[in_sevraj]

i got a quest
i was playng a game
in scourge team 2 guys leave i was typing sw and 1 guy for scourge reject sw offer and then he leave cause he said the rulle sayd if 3v5 he can leave
can i ban him ?
not ban abusse or some so he can get unbanned with unban req?
the game was so
can u help me in this problem?

[NiGhT^^StAlKeR]

U dont have to switch.So u cant ban that guy he did all by the rules.

Link of the game would be nice to confirm ur story.

[DuffMan]

Well as I understand it
1. its not obligatory to !yes when someone !switch.
2. u may leave 5v3 game under some conditions, BUT I FOUND THIS precise rule

" If number of players in the opposing team is greater then 2 players and the game mode does not include -so (-switchon) you are free to leave the game without ban;
               After playing 35mins, switching is not necessary."

So it means 1. !yes is not obligatory, but
                   2. u cannot leave 5v3 game if its -so
                   3. "after 35 min..." it dont say anything COZ IMHO its not obligatory to !yes

[DuffMan]

U dont have to switch.So u cant ban that guy he did all by the rules.

Link of the game would be nice to confirm ur story.

agree u cannot be forced to switch, but - as rule say - u cannot leave 5v3 game when its -so

(I think this need some "high ranked mod" to solve - coz its quite funny situation when its 5v3 (for ex after 15 min) somebody reject swtich and u cannot leave according to rules)

[in_sevraj]

this guy reject the offer and then leave is not fair for his team mates so..........
he desserve ban but...........

[Shadow]

I would definitely ban him...

[NiGhT^^StAlKeR]

Listen. If u have situation 3v5 u cant leave if there is SO . But if some1 rejects switch u are free to leave.

[in_sevraj]

http://stats.playdota.eu/?p=gameinfo&gid=1311323
this is the link of the game
so let me understand if i dont like the situation i can reject the sw offer and then i can leave the game?
lol it mean i can make a lot of stats like that

[DuffMan]

Listen. If u have situation 3v5 u cant leave if there is SO . But if some1 rejects switch u are free to leave.

where is written - if someone reject switch u are free to leave?
Or its just widely accepted interpretation of rules I posted a bit more up? So that means if there is 1 unsuccesfull try to switch youre free to leave (or how many unsuccesfull !switch)?

[NiGhT^^StAlKeR]

Listen. If u have situation 3v5 u cant leave if there is SO . But if some1 rejects switch u are free to leave.

where is written - if someone reject switch u are free to leave?
Or its just widely accepted interpretation of rules I posted a bit more up? So that means if there is 1 unsuccesfull try to switch youre free to leave (or how many unsuccesfull !switch)?

Its not so good determinated by rules but it means that in 3v5 situation u can leave.SO or not SO

[iPlayForFun]

Post ban request. When all want switch, and he dont want ok, but he cant leave that is rule break.

[DuffMan]

Post ban request. When all want switch, and he dont want ok, but he cant leave that is rule break.

hooray - official interpretation
so if its 5v3 game with -so and somebody dont wanna !yes = nobody can leave?

[iPlayForFun]

Post ban request. When all want switch, and he dont want ok, but he cant leave that is rule break.

hooray - official interpretation
so if its 5v3 game with -so and somebody dont wanna !yes = nobody can leave?

NOTES: If number of players in the opposing team is greater than 3 players and the game mode includes -so (-switchon) you are free to leave the game without ban;
               If number of players in the opposing team is greater then 2 players and the game mode does not include -so (-switchon) you are free to leave the game without ban;
               After playing 35mins, switching is not necessary.

It means that if it is 5v2 u are free to leave, but if it is 5v3 and there is -so u are not free to leave.

[mrNiceguy]

It means that if it is 5v2 u are free to leave, but if it is 5v3 and there is -so u are not free to leave.

Yes he is free to leave Iplayforfun, cause you cant force anyone to switch. So he refused switch and he left game, it was his right to do that. If he wants lose in his stats then it is up to him.

[iPlayForFun]

He just go -no cuz he wanted to leave, all sentinels want switch and they want to keep playing. He just weisted their time for me that is ban and i will always ban ppl like him!!!