SOTW #68 Voting

[LexMonster]

SOTW #68 voting!




1


2


3


4


5

Everyone has 2 votes: 2 points and 1 point

Note: For fair voting, ALL participants are obligated to vote before voting has ended. All participants who did not vote, but participated, can not be rewarded as winners in case their picture has most of points collected. In that case, official winner will be next picture with most points collected. All participants has at least 4 days to vote. This rule apply for everyone, without exceptions!
If participant was/will be inactive in/before voting period on forum, then he have to contact gfx staff members and to inform us about inactivity.

[ilikedat]

2 points    -> 2
1 point      -> 3

[GREED]

i foken hate jugio
2-2
1-3

[LexMonster]

If I may share my oppinion..

1 - render should have been placed 1/4 to the left and text 1/4 to the right, that way they would be in the middle and they would make nice focal point. Putting them in corner was not good. I like the background, but you should've blur it a bit, so render and text would pop out.

3 - Very good sig, nice render, good flow, but no focal point. You should've blured background also. BG looks nice, but I dont see connection between Yugi and leaves  But it looks nice still. I rly like the font too, well done! Btw, you streched render a bit (to make it fit?) but you should've just shrink it, it would look much better

4 - nice render and text placement. Text is well designed, to incorporate with BG and render, but its too sharp (and I know it bcus you use online editors instead of real PS!) and pops out too much. There is no flow also

I hope this helps you, and that next time,you ll pay attention on things I mentioned, and that you'll improve your GFX skills


With all that being said, I vote for number 3 (2 points) and number 4 (1 point)

[Meth0d]

Lex dont be such a smart guy .... I know why i did this ... cuz render was like that ... i was thinkig of middle too .... but wouldnt be better maybe with other render , but others are shity for me and btw i dont even like this theme ^^ ..... i will tell you only one thing , i was check few of last sotw and i have to tell im disappointed with works really .... When i was active sotw was on another lvl

[LexMonster]

Lex dont be such a smart guy .... I know why i did this ... cuz render was like that ... i was thinkig of middle too .... but wouldnt be better maybe with other render , but others are shity for me and btw i dont even like this theme ^^ ..... i will tell you only one thing , i was check few of last sotw and i have to tell im disappointed with works really .... When i was active sotw was on another lvl

I couldnt agree more, there were many GFX pros, who are no longer active..
Rockafella, [cro]Edge, Dolmel, Icy-pig, Deeldo, [GER]S.T.A.R and photoshop God Dr.S
Those were the competitions..

[.SaLiH.]

here you go:P soon i'll be back i think.

[Lagi]

If I may share my oppinion..

3 - Very good sig, nice render, good flow, but no focal point. You should've blured background also. BG looks nice, but I dont see connection between Yugi and leaves  But it looks nice still. I rly like the font too, well done! Btw, you streched render a bit (to make it fit?) but you should've just shrink it, it would look much better

Well, the whole yu gi oh era is a bit gay for me, so I don't watch it and therefore I have no idea what things can fit/have connection to this yugi guy I picked up randomly. I basically just wanted to make smth that looks cool because I'm not familiar with this theme/topic to have any concept in my mind. Btw I didn't stretch anything, except that circle-like render(https://i1.creativecow.net/u/38325/screenshot2010-10-19at1.52.31pm.jpg), which I used as some kind of "light-trails" behind his finger on the left to make it look like his hand is in movement, that's why i streched it into a huge ellipse. About focal point you are right I will try to avoid this mistake in the future. Also I just realized that I forgot to cut out a huge chunk of white part from the yugi render, that's why it is white at his neck/shoulder xDDD I seriously didn't realize it before at all

Ok Back to serious business:

My vote:

2points for 2
1point for 1.

I would have vote 2pts for entry no.1, but for my taste, it is too much "oversaturated" on the right side.

[ilikedat]

2 points    -> 2
1 point      -> 3

[iErnesto94]

5-2p
1-1p

[KeMCek]

5 ====> 2 point
1 ====> 1 point

[Lagi]

2 - 2
5 - 1

[LexMonster]

3 - 2pts
5 - 1pt

[Nexxus]

5 2pts

3 1pt

[Renovatio]

2 points > No. 2
1 point   > No. 4