Remove game from stats if there is a proven maphacker.

[SillyMe]

Here's an idea:

There are so many maphackers and it is so easy for them to avoid ban (new account) that you sometimes get discouraged from checking and posting mh report. They will make a new account and (in case you lost) your psr will still unfairly be lower.

My proposition is that if a game had at least one proven maphacker in it (MH report followed by hack admin validation) then that game should be removed from stats for all players.

The benefit of this would be that if you lose because of maphackers your PSR won't be affected. Also this adds an extra incentive to check replays and report maphackers.

Of course there are games where you play against maphackers and still win but I think that even in those cases sending a strong message against maphack is still more important than the loss in PSR (others might disagree). We could also argue that sometimes a maphacker might cause his own team to lose just by being stupid (forgetting that not everyone sees what he sees) and getting himself (or even the entire team) in impossible situations.

Even if a game ends up being removed because of maphackers all other players must abide by the rules until the game ends (leaving the game before it is finished or going AFK will still be punished - so... no monkey business until you have proof).

This might not seem so important for higher level games but I think it will make a difference for pubs (where 99% of the maphackers are).

Please don't close this thread too quickly and give the people a chance to comment.

Thanks.

[Alucardo]

ok here is my opinion

i disagree with ur idea.it will be unfair to many players.lets say i joined a game.. i had fun and i won it but however since there is 1 map hacker in my team its going to be deleted from stat page.. whats my fault in that?

also in noob games which is made basically of multi accounters.. there is a chance close to 100% that there will be 1 mher in game so at this rate almost all games wont be recorded because of 1 mher in the game..

also lets say your idea is nice and we all agree to it.. still normal moderators cant remove game from stats

there are other reasons .. but these are the basic reasons

[kingW3]

I would agree on this idea when the multi account protection is up

[donjacrtasamir]

ok here is my opinion

i disagree with ur idea.it will be unfair to many players.lets say i joined a game.. i had fun and i won it but however since there is 1 map hacker in my team its going to be deleted from stat page.. whats my fault in that?

also in noob games which is made basically of multi accounters.. there is a chance close to 100% that there will be 1 mher in game so at this rate almost all games wont be recorded because of 1 mher in the game..

also lets say your idea is nice and we all agree to it.. still normal moderators cant remove game from stats

there are other reasons .. but these are the basic reasons

+1

sillyMe's idea in other words remove psr ...

[DatFace]

Guys you talk about ideas etc..its easy to tell!
but you ask if mun or someone else can do this things?

[ColdWorld]

I would agree on this idea when the multi account protection is up

+

[Rio^]

Guys you talk about ideas etc..its easy to tell!
but you ask if mun or someone else can do this things?

+1.

It's always like that

[kingW3]

Guys you talk about ideas etc..its easy to tell!
but you ask if mun or someone else can do this things?

-1
Deleting games from stats is easy to do,even making it automated but it's a bit harder

[GREED]

I would agree on this idea when the multi account protection is up

when or if when?

[Angel]

And what if you have the situation where the maphacker is in the winning team but he is a completly noob, so he doesn't contribute anything for his team. Shall the game be deleted even then?

I understand that maphackers are affecting the PSR of many players, but also those who are on the top have passed that 'hard way to the throne'. So, it's kind of equal for everyone.

[DatFace]

And what if you have the situation where the maphacker is in the winning team but he is a completly noob, so he doesn't contribute anything for his team. Shall the game be deleted even then?

I understand that maphackers are affecting the PSR of many players, but also those who are on the top have passed that 'hard way to the throne'. So, it's kind of equal for everyone.

yeah i agree here!